Home » Make Ahead Stuffed Bell Peppers

Make Ahead Stuffed Bell Peppers

Make ahead stuffed bell peppers with ground turkey.

In my nesting phase I planned to make a ton of meals to freeze. Make Ahead Stuffed Bell Peppers can be prepped a day in advance and frozen for later.

If you read this post you know that my baby girl came three weeks early. Luckily, I had a good amount of prep work done! A friend had brought a batch of stuffed bell peppers when my son was born and they were both comforting and healthy. I decided to make them to have on hand for baby’s arrival.

This recipe can be altered to fit vegetarian and vegan diets; different spices can alter the menu to be more Italian or Mexican inspired. Keep reading to see how I make the recipe!

Gather ingredients.

Make Ahead Stuffed Bell Peppers ingredients

I use ground turkey and set some aside for my son. Basically he eats all of the stuffing without the pepper.

Mushrooms help to keep the turkey moist. Bonus- when I dice them small enough, my son has no idea they are mixed in!

My friend used quinoa instead of rice like I had grown up with. Quinoa is high in protein and fiber, and a good alternative to rice.

Beans add more protein and when mixed with a taco seasoning, make this dish have a Mexican flavor.

Slice off tops of peppers.

Make Ahead Stuffed Bell Peppers cut bell pepper

Slice the tops of the bell peppers just enough to leave room for the filling.

Remove the seeds and insides of the peppers.

I grew up with green bell peppers in this recipe, but I much prefer the red, yellow, or orange peppers.

Dice mushrooms into small pieces.

Dice mushrooms

As I mentioned, I dice them small enough for my son to miss them!

Sautee onion for mushrooms & ground turkey.

Brown onions

While sautéing the onions and mushrooms, boil the quinoa per package instructions. You can start this step bfore chopping as well.

I like to make turkey stuffed bell peppers, but you can substitute ground beef, or skip meat altogether.

Brown ground turkey, then add beans and quinoa.

Make Ahead Stuffed Bell Peppers

Add the taco seasoning as you brown the turkey.

Corn or tomatoes would also be good options to add.

Fill bell peppers with ground turkey mix.

Make Ahead Stuffed Bell Peppers

Top with cheese.

Make Ahead Stuffed Bell Peppers with cheese

You can cut calories and skip the cheese. You can also double down on cheese by mixing some in the filling as well as on top.

I’ve made these a day ahead, stored them in a baking pan covered with plastic wrap or foil, and then baked the next day.

This dish is an easy way to pack in lots of veggies, save time, and feed a crowd.

Ingredients

Instructions

  1. Dice onion
  2. Slice off tops of peppers and remove insides.
  3. Dice mushrooms
  4. Sautee onion and mushrooms in olive oil.
  5. Cook quinoa per package instructions while other ingredients are cooking.
  6. Add ground turkey and taco seasoning to pan with the onion and mushroom and cook for 10 minutes or until no longer pink (cooking thermometer reaches 165)
  7. Once turkey meat is cooked, stir in beans and cooked quinoa.
  8. Scoop the mix to fill the peppers.
  9. Sprinkle tops of filled peppers with cheese if desired.
  10. Placed stuffed peppers in a baking dish. I use a 9×13″ cake pan. Pour water that covers the bottom of the pepper.
  11. Bake covered at 350 for 10 minutes. Uncover and bake for an additional 15 minutes or until cheese is melted and filling is warm.

Shop This Dear Casa Kitchen

More yummy recipes

I love a hearty slice of sweet bread with coffee or tea, just like this date bread.

This broccoli recipe is kicked up a notch with sprinkled parmesan!

I love baked apples for an easy fall dessert.

17 thoughts on “Make Ahead Stuffed Bell Peppers”

    1. I grew up with these but sort of forgot about them until a friend made them for me. And yes, the red, yellow & orange are more sweet. I didn’t like green peppers as a kid and I still don’t ☺️ Thanks for stopping by!

  1. I love stuffed peppers but usually make them with beef – I definitely want to try this recipe as it looks so delicious!

  2. You mentioned taco seasoning in the list of ingredients but did not include it in the instructions. When is it added to the dish ???

    1. Hi there! Leave out the ground turkey and you still have the beans, quinoa, mushroom. My vegetarian friend makes them this way. You could add more veggies like corn, zucchini etc. Have a great day!

Leave a Reply